Comparing Two Alcohol Screening Measures on Rates of Risky Alcohol Use in a University Health Clinic
artículo original
Date
2019Author
McCabe, Brian
Stark, Gisel
Halstead, Valerie
Muñoz Rojas, Derby
Gelberg, Lilian
Pantin, Hilda
Prado, Guillermo
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
College drinking is a serious health concern. Few studies have examined screening measures
and methods of administration. This study compares two alcohol screens (NIAAA 5/4 binge
drinking question or Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT)) in a college student
health clinic waiting room and two modes of administration (self-administered either on a
computer kiosk or on a tablet computer). Participants were 259 undergraduates from the
University of Miami. Most (78–98%) students completed screening. More students were
identified with risky alcohol use with the 5/4 (49%) than AUDIT (14%). On the 5/4,
administration method was not linked to completion, 93% kiosk vs. 95% tablet, p = .554,
but was related to identification as a risky alcohol user, 42% kiosk vs. 56% tablet, p = .033. On
the AUDIT, administration method was significantly related to completion, 73% kiosk vs. 98%
tablet, p < .001, and identification, 8% kiosk vs. 23% tablet, p = .003. Method of administration
of the single item 5/4 binge drinking question was related to the a higher proportion of
students identified with risky alcohol use when screened by a computer tablet, but not
completion rates; the AUDIT method of administration was related to both completion and
identification rates (higher rates with the tablet in both cases). Education of student health
providers who make decisions about what screening tools to use in their centers and who
interpret the results of alcohol screening in college health centers should consider the potential
influence of administration method. Future research should examine the reasons that method
of administration might influence screening results.
External link to the item
10.1007/s11469-019-00072-7Collections
- Enfermería [167]